godshammgod said:
This weekend a friend and I had a sort of impromptu beer tasting as part of a larger game night among friends. I brought over a couple of barrel-aged limited releases from Jack's Abby (Peanut Butter and Jelly and Cocoa-Nut Framinghammers, which are bourbon barrel-aged Baltic Porters). He had just returned from a Vermont beercation, so he shared some Hill Farmstead Everett, and of course, some Heady Topper. Heady was delicious, as expected, but I was actually more impressed by Everett, which I knew of, but had not read much about. It hit you with a punch of dark chocolate, before finishing with this great smokiness.
Of the IPAs/hoppys I got on our New England adventure in May, Heady Topper ranked near the bottom of my personal scale. I much preferred The Alchemist's other IPA release, Focal Banger. In addition, all four Lawson's Finest I had (Sip of Sunshine, Ava, Session and Triple Sunshine) were better, as was Fiddlehead's Second Fiddle (criminally under-recognized Burlington/Shelburne, VT spot, keep an eye on them).
Don't get me wrong, it was a solid beer but not life-changing. A buddy had sent me a four-pack a few years back (pre-flood, from the old place when they just started canning) and it was quasi-orgasmically fantabulous. However, this trip Heady just didn't hold the same sway for me.
HF Everett rivals the best American porters out there and I wouldn't argue that it belongs at the top (not my favorite style but I have learned to enjoy it in moderation). Got a growler at the brewery on our visit, also really dug their single-hop Amarillo Pale from their offerings that day. Regret only getting four bottles of Arthur though.