American Idol Finale 5/22

[Webster]

Can I still vote for Melinda? Jordin clearly was better tonight, but last week's result ruined the finale for me.

Amen. I spotted Melinda in two, three different shots during the show. She didn't smile once. Melinda should have been in the finals, no doubt.

The more that I think about it, the more that I think that Randy's comments were the reason that Melinda was voted out. It was clear that Simon liked Melinda and that Randy liked Jordin. In fact, Randy has been so over the top with his praise for Jordin that it is a little sickening. Meanwhile, he never forgot to tell the audience that Melinda was "a pro" and his always praised her "consistency". I think that he wanted to make sure that it wasn't a Jordin-Melinda final because Melinda is the better singer. By having Blake-Jordin, he could go back to comparing singing voices.

I thought that Simon has a good dig at Randy, saying something like "now that I've been reminded that this is a singing competition"

 

[Montezuma's Revenge]

You give Randy credit for having WAY more influence than he does.

 

[ADifferentOkie]

Two things...
They showed the finalists in the audience, but did anyone ever spot Gina.
What was with the rotating celebs in the first row.. first song, Denise Richards was in the back ground kinda over Simon's left shoulder... second song, gone... third song, someone else

I never saw Gina. OR Sanjaya. Howard Stern said on his show Sanjaya is suing Idol because he thinks the results were fixed. Did anyone hear that?

I definitely saw Sanjaya in the background of one shot. I never spotted Gina.

 

[ADifferentOkie]

Anyone that thinks Clarkson is a bigger hit than Underwood simply isn't paying attention to anything. It's not even close. In career development or looks.

I think Jordin wins, but she didn't blow me away tonight. Average at best. Blake sucked. Big time. Very disappointing show.

Clarkson is the superior singer and will outlast Underwood.

You're just wrong on both counts.

 

[Yawn]

This was a Super Bowl blowout.

And I know a lot of people who shut the TV down after last week. This ain't a singing competition. This is a schtick competition, Hollywood style. Best marketable story. Jordin, Phillippi's little girl. 17, innocence. Hope she stays that way, but you know how Hollywood changes people.

But there is no way - no way at all - that either of these people are superior in voice to Melinda.

 

[Billy Monday]

Why is Paula Abdul a judge if she never wants to judge anybody?

She says the same thing about everybody: "You're super. I love you. You're really coming into your own."

Then when asked who she thinks was better, even if it's clear to the rest of the world, she says, "It's a tie. I can't choose."

This annoys the effing hell out of me.

Don't sign up for the job as judge if you're afraid to do the darn job!

It reminds me of sissy writers who just want to genuflect with famous athletes instead of doing our job telling it like it is and exposing their bull.

 

[Cansportschick]

I actually feel for Blake. I disagreed with Simon's comment last night that his Maroon 5 performance would be deemed unforgettable. I actually thought it was good. However, Simon was right in saying that it would be unfair to judge Blake on the last song because it is clearly not his genre of music or type of song he would sing.

I am starting not to like Randy as a judge on the show. I am at times wondering if he is on the same page as everyone else (like what he is listening to).

It was clear last night that no matter what Blake sang, Randy wasn't going to like it because he was totally in Jordin's camp. Simon is still sulking over Melinda's exit (I don't blame him).

I won't be buying Jordin's record that is for sure. If Blake puts out one, I will get it because I like unique talent. Melinda should have won Idol though for sure. I think if you are the front runner, it is a curse every year or something because you tend to get voted out :

 

[Lugnuts]

I really wanted Blake to do Somewhere Only We Know for his "repeat." He can sing, and he had done a beautiful job with that song.

I read an interview with Nigel Lythgoe... I think in Variety... where he said they blew it this year by getting away from the personal stories and doing too much with the "mentors" who were promoting albums. Couldn't agree more! I'm so glad he gets it. This whole season, I kept asking, "Where are the shots of Vonzell doing her mail route, or Anthony Federov growing up in Russia?"

The producers dropped the ball this year, and as a result the viewers were less invested in the contestants. Happy to see it will be corrected.

 

[Flash]

Blake wins. It will be about the teen vote.

 

[slappy4428]

Ms. Slappy saw Sanjayjay several times on TV

 

[Oz]

Blake wins. It will be about the teen vote.

I don't know why the teen wouldn't get as many teen votes as Blake. I see them even there.

 

[Flash]

Blake wins. It will be about the teen vote.

I don't know why the teen wouldn't get as many teen votes as Blake. I see them even there.

Fox does this crazy poll relevant to web searches for the Idol's name ... it had Blake well ahead of Jordin, who just nipped Melinda.

Teenage girls will vote for the cute boy. Not the Amazon that can sing.