PCLoadLetter
Well-Known Member
playthrough said:PCLoadLetter said:playthrough said:crimsonace said:imjustagirl said:Pilot said:The ABC signoff from the actual race was pretty powerful: "Many people ask me why I always sign off 'Till we meet again.' Because goodbye is always so final. Goodbye, Dan Wheldon."
That literally has just sent me into sobs on my couch.
Marty Reid has been criticized a lot (and a lot of it justifiably) for his work, but he and Cheever/Goodyear handled today's events beautifully. ABC's producers missed a big one (and I can understand why -- everything was happening very quickly) by not getting the live feed of Bernard announcing the death up until he had already announced it -- thereby forcing Reid to do so -- but he handled it very well.
Did not get a chance to hear Mike King's signoff on radio. He and Wheldon were very close. The gold standard is Sid Collins' eulogy of Eddie Sachs. But Reid hit it out of the park. Simple, understated, and perfect for the moment.
Being late to Bernard was a huge, inexcusable mistake. You could hear someone whispering to ask confirmation if he was dead, since they missed the first few seconds, and that made me cringe.
As someone who produces live TV, I'll cut the broadcast team some slack. The guy walked into the room, picked up the mic and immediately started talking. Without some level of warning it's a bench to get the front end of something like that live.
IndyCar needs to give a warning so the broadcaster is ready to take it.
But shouldn't you err on the other side then, maybe showing an empty table for an extra two seconds to make sure you get Bernard as he starts? I'm sure it's very hectic and not easy (and it's a testament to racing today that this was probably the first death for a lot of people involved in the coverage), but the audience was waiting for, what, 90 minutes or so for that one moment?
It's totally a question of whether the people calling the shots for the broadcast know the announcement is imminent. As a producer I'll be happy to sit on an empty table for two seconds. I won't do it for a half hour.
I'll put it this way: when the President is going to speak the networks are given a one minute warning. Then the President walks into the room, makes a long walk to the mic, stands there for a moment, says "good morning," then starts talking. It's set up to make it smooth on TV.
In this case, Bernard walked briskly into a small room, grabbed the mic and said "Dan Wheldon passed away." Without really solid advanced warning, you're not going to hit that cleanly.