doctorquant said:
LongTimeListener said:
YankeeFan said:
they didn't let racism get in their way.
By and large white people didn't let racism get in the immigrants' way either. At least not nearly to the degree they did with African-Americans. That's a part of it you're not getting.
Starting from zero is a lot better than starting from negative 1,000.
OK, so let's stipulate that many poor/uneducated African-Americans start at, as you put it, negative 1,000. For example, think of that heartbreaking story of that little girl ... Dasani? ... in the
New York Times awhile back. Is it your contention that white racism is why she's very likely to
stay at negative 1,000?
It depends how broadly you want to go. I am assuming (and it might have said in the story) that if she is 6, her grandparents are somewhere between 40 and 45. Think about the home life of an African-American child born to uneducated parents between 1969 and 1974 in New York City. Is that a model for success, as most of our parents gave us? It's the cycle we all know about.
So take "illegal" drugs out of it and concentrate on things that happen in white households. If parents smoke, children are far more likely to smoke. If parents drink heavily, children are far more likely to drink heavily. Why, then, would we expect it to be different regarding the far more addictive drugs of crack and heroin? And why is it reasonable to think a multi-generational family that has never had any exposure or opportunity for "the good life" of education and stability would suddenly find it in the form of a 17-year-old teenage girl? Unfortunately, Dasani's path was almost assuredly set at birth. And society at large bears an enormous burden for that.
Regarding white racism of today ... nobody is going to call it racism. But yes, the deck is stacked almost impossibly against her.
--White flight, either to the suburbs or to private schools, has re-segregated the school system to almost as large a degree as it was before Brown v. Board of Education.
--College acceptance has been set up almost entirely to favor white people, with its near-singular focus on standardized tests and the rise of prep programs that cost thousands of dollars.
--Remember Trayvon Martin's girlfriend on the witness stand and the way she was so roundly and gleefully mocked on the witness stand? That's probably how Dasani is going to sound in 10 years, because that is local dialect. And that was ugly, ugly racism at its worst.
So, yeah ... as a matter of individuals, the great shame is that her parents provide nothing. But returning to what deck has been saying, why is that? How is it that one portion of society -- and the one that has been mistreated the most viciously and violently -- stays so far behind the curve? The answer is either that there's a big historical problem, or that black people just aren't as good as the rest of us.