Best QB In NFL History!!!

RAMBO · Feb 5, 2007

Bob Sacamano said:

Marnio was overrated.
Click to expand...

Now why would you say something like that.

RAMBO · Feb 5, 2007

Chuck~Taylor said:

slappy4428 said:

RAMBO said:

Chuck~Taylor said:

Moses Moreno

But seriously, when it's all said and done, Manning will be the greatest.
Click to expand...

Thank you Chuck finally we get some brains around this damn site.
Click to expand...

And a ringing endorsement of Chuck it is...
Click to expand...

I have a brain?
Click to expand...

No I was just pulling your leg.

RAMBO · Feb 5, 2007

HeinekenMan said:

These arguments are nothing but rhetoric. Several years ago, my friend and I came to the realization that you can't compare Jordan to Magic or Bird. Each was special in a unique way, and each had multiple variables that can't be weighed.

Such is the case with this quarterback discussion. I mean, I couldn't even begin to answer this. Marino was a stude who never won the big game and never had shit for a running game. Elway is in the same class and deserves serious consideration because he won two Super Bowls. But Montana won, what, three? He wasn't as prolific, but he was great in the clutch. Of course, he also threw to the greatest wide receiver in the game for a few seasons. I'm not sure whether he won much after Rice arrived and I don't care to do the research.

I don't think Brady belongs in the discussion, but he gets a lot of points if you emphasize Super Bowls. But I don't put too much weight on them because they take so much more than a good quarterback. Trent Dilfer won a Super Bowl, don't forget that.

I suppose Favre and Elway are the most similar of the bunch, for whatever that's worth. I won't pretend to be knowledgeable when it comes to Unitas. Obviously, he was the best of his era, but I don't have any frame of reference. As far as I'm concerned, he's just one of a group that also includes Tarkenton, Starr, Staubach, Bradshaw, Jurgenson.

And there are tons of guys who could chuck the ball. I started watching in the early '80s, and I saw a lot of great QBs. Cinci had a guy, Ken something. Plunkett was superb. Danny White wasn't bad. I even thought Boomer was decent.

My guy, though, is always going to be Warren Moon. He's my favorite because he played for my team. I also like him because he's the forgotten guy, the underdog. Moon missed some seasons while playing in the CF, and those were good seasons. He's in the CFL Hall of Fame.

Now, Warren never won a Super Bowl, but he came damned close at least twice. There was the game with the Bills that Houston blew after leading 35-3 at the half. And I don't think anyone can dispute that Moon was a part of the history of black quarterbacks in the league. In fact, unless I'm mistaken, he's the first black quarterback to make the Hall of Fame.
Click to expand...

One mistake there buddy Montana won 4 SuperBowls.

GB-Hack · Feb 5, 2007

I've always said Montana, but if Manning keeps up the pace he's on he could easily surpass him. The interesting stat I got from Peter King's column today was that while Favre is only seven TD's behind Marnio [sic] on the all-time list, Manning is only 145 behind.

Five more seasons with 30 TD passes and he'd take Marnio's total. Manning may end up with all the records, and now at least one title.

RAMBO · Feb 5, 2007

GB-Hack said:

I've always said Montana, but if Manning keeps up the pace he's on he could easily surpass him. The interesting stat I got from Peter King's column today was that while Favre is only seven TD's behind Marnio [sic] on the all-time list, Manning is only 145 behind.

Five more seasons with 30 TD passes and he'd take Marnio's total. Manning may end up with all the records, and now at least one title.
Click to expand...

To tell you the truth I thought Manning was HOF and the best of all-time after he retires and he did not need that ring to prove himself because he was great before hand.

HeinekenMan · Feb 5, 2007

RAMBO said:

HeinekenMan said:

These arguments are nothing but rhetoric. Several years ago, my friend and I came to the realization that you can't compare Jordan to Magic or Bird. Each was special in a unique way, and each had multiple variables that can't be weighed.

Such is the case with this quarterback discussion. I mean, I couldn't even begin to answer this. Marino was a stude who never won the big game and never had shit for a running game. Elway is in the same class and deserves serious consideration because he won two Super Bowls. But Montana won, what, three? He wasn't as prolific, but he was great in the clutch. Of course, he also threw to the greatest wide receiver in the game for a few seasons. I'm not sure whether he won much after Rice arrived and I don't care to do the research.

I don't think Brady belongs in the discussion, but he gets a lot of points if you emphasize Super Bowls. But I don't put too much weight on them because they take so much more than a good quarterback. Trent Dilfer won a Super Bowl, don't forget that.

I suppose Favre and Elway are the most similar of the bunch, for whatever that's worth. I won't pretend to be knowledgeable when it comes to Unitas. Obviously, he was the best of his era, but I don't have any frame of reference. As far as I'm concerned, he's just one of a group that also includes Tarkenton, Starr, Staubach, Bradshaw, Jurgenson.

And there are tons of guys who could chuck the ball. I started watching in the early '80s, and I saw a lot of great QBs. Cinci had a guy, Ken something. Plunkett was superb. Danny White wasn't bad. I even thought Boomer was decent.

My guy, though, is always going to be Warren Moon. He's my favorite because he played for my team. I also like him because he's the forgotten guy, the underdog. Moon missed some seasons while playing in the CF, and those were good seasons. He's in the CFL Hall of Fame.

Now, Warren never won a Super Bowl, but he came damned close at least twice. There was the game with the Bills that Houston blew after leading 35-3 at the half. And I don't think anyone can dispute that Moon was a part of the history of black quarterbacks in the league. In fact, unless I'm mistaken, he's the first black quarterback to make the Hall of Fame.
Click to expand...

One mistake there buddy Montana won 4 SuperBowls.
Click to expand...

Well, I refuse to recognize the Montana-to-Clark miracle pass that booted my Cowboys out the big game.

RAMBO · Feb 5, 2007

HeinekenMan said:

RAMBO said:

HeinekenMan said:

These arguments are nothing but rhetoric. Several years ago, my friend and I came to the realization that you can't compare Jordan to Magic or Bird. Each was special in a unique way, and each had multiple variables that can't be weighed.

Such is the case with this quarterback discussion. I mean, I couldn't even begin to answer this. Marino was a stude who never won the big game and never had shit for a running game. Elway is in the same class and deserves serious consideration because he won two Super Bowls. But Montana won, what, three? He wasn't as prolific, but he was great in the clutch. Of course, he also threw to the greatest wide receiver in the game for a few seasons. I'm not sure whether he won much after Rice arrived and I don't care to do the research.

I don't think Brady belongs in the discussion, but he gets a lot of points if you emphasize Super Bowls. But I don't put too much weight on them because they take so much more than a good quarterback. Trent Dilfer won a Super Bowl, don't forget that.

I suppose Favre and Elway are the most similar of the bunch, for whatever that's worth. I won't pretend to be knowledgeable when it comes to Unitas. Obviously, he was the best of his era, but I don't have any frame of reference. As far as I'm concerned, he's just one of a group that also includes Tarkenton, Starr, Staubach, Bradshaw, Jurgenson.

And there are tons of guys who could chuck the ball. I started watching in the early '80s, and I saw a lot of great QBs. Cinci had a guy, Ken something. Plunkett was superb. Danny White wasn't bad. I even thought Boomer was decent.

My guy, though, is always going to be Warren Moon. He's my favorite because he played for my team. I also like him because he's the forgotten guy, the underdog. Moon missed some seasons while playing in the CF, and those were good seasons. He's in the CFL Hall of Fame.

Now, Warren never won a Super Bowl, but he came damned close at least twice. There was the game with the Bills that Houston blew after leading 35-3 at the half. And I don't think anyone can dispute that Moon was a part of the history of black quarterbacks in the league. In fact, unless I'm mistaken, he's the first black quarterback to make the Hall of Fame.
Click to expand...

One mistake there buddy Montana won 4 SuperBowls.
Click to expand...

Well, I refuse to recognize the Montana-to-Clark miracle pass that booted my Cowboys out the big game.
Click to expand...

Hey if you bring out the stats then just do it right and make it fair.

outofplace · Feb 5, 2007

HeinekenMan said:

These arguments are nothing but rhetoric. Several years ago, my friend and I came to the realization that you can't compare Jordan to Magic or Bird. Each was special in a unique way, and each had multiple variables that can't be weighed.

Such is the case with this quarterback discussion. I mean, I couldn't even begin to answer this. Marino was a stude who never won the big game and never had shit for a running game. Elway is in the same class and deserves serious consideration because he won two Super Bowls. But Montana won, what, three? He wasn't as prolific, but he was great in the clutch. Of course, he also threw to the greatest wide receiver in the game for a few seasons. I'm not sure whether he won much after Rice arrived and I don't care to do the research.

I don't think Brady belongs in the discussion, but he gets a lot of points if you emphasize Super Bowls. But I don't put too much weight on them because they take so much more than a good quarterback. Trent Dilfer won a Super Bowl, don't forget that.

I suppose Favre and Elway are the most similar of the bunch, for whatever that's worth. I won't pretend to be knowledgeable when it comes to Unitas. Obviously, he was the best of his era, but I don't have any frame of reference. As far as I'm concerned, he's just one of a group that also includes Tarkenton, Starr, Staubach, Bradshaw, Jurgenson.

And there are tons of guys who could chuck the ball. I started watching in the early '80s, and I saw a lot of great QBs. Cinci had a guy, Ken something. Plunkett was superb. Danny White wasn't bad. I even thought Boomer was decent.

My guy, though, is always going to be Warren Moon. He's my favorite because he played for my team. I also like him because he's the forgotten guy, the underdog. Moon missed some seasons while playing in the CF, and those were good seasons. He's in the CFL Hall of Fame.

Now, Warren never won a Super Bowl, but he came damned close at least twice. There was the game with the Bills that Houston blew after leading 35-3 at the half. And I don't think anyone can dispute that Moon was a part of the history of black quarterbacks in the league. In fact, unless I'm mistaken, he's the first black quarterback to make the Hall of Fame.
Click to expand...

And he (Moon) smacked around his wife. Let's not forget that on his resume.

HeinekenMan · Feb 5, 2007

outofplace said:

HeinekenMan said:

These arguments are nothing but rhetoric. Several years ago, my friend and I came to the realization that you can't compare Jordan to Magic or Bird. Each was special in a unique way, and each had multiple variables that can't be weighed.

Such is the case with this quarterback discussion. I mean, I couldn't even begin to answer this. Marino was a stude who never won the big game and never had shit for a running game. Elway is in the same class and deserves serious consideration because he won two Super Bowls. But Montana won, what, three? He wasn't as prolific, but he was great in the clutch. Of course, he also threw to the greatest wide receiver in the game for a few seasons. I'm not sure whether he won much after Rice arrived and I don't care to do the research.

I don't think Brady belongs in the discussion, but he gets a lot of points if you emphasize Super Bowls. But I don't put too much weight on them because they take so much more than a good quarterback. Trent Dilfer won a Super Bowl, don't forget that.

I suppose Favre and Elway are the most similar of the bunch, for whatever that's worth. I won't pretend to be knowledgeable when it comes to Unitas. Obviously, he was the best of his era, but I don't have any frame of reference. As far as I'm concerned, he's just one of a group that also includes Tarkenton, Starr, Staubach, Bradshaw, Jurgenson.

And there are tons of guys who could chuck the ball. I started watching in the early '80s, and I saw a lot of great QBs. Cinci had a guy, Ken something. Plunkett was superb. Danny White wasn't bad. I even thought Boomer was decent.

My guy, though, is always going to be Warren Moon. He's my favorite because he played for my team. I also like him because he's the forgotten guy, the underdog. Moon missed some seasons while playing in the CF, and those were good seasons. He's in the CFL Hall of Fame.

Now, Warren never won a Super Bowl, but he came damned close at least twice. There was the game with the Bills that Houston blew after leading 35-3 at the half. And I don't think anyone can dispute that Moon was a part of the history of black quarterbacks in the league. In fact, unless I'm mistaken, he's the first black quarterback to make the Hall of Fame.
Click to expand...

And he (Moon) smacked around his wife. Let's not forget that on his resume.
Click to expand...

What the fuck is that? I suppose you're perfect? I believe Moon's wife changed her story after the police arrived. I don't know what the truth is, but I know better than to cast stones. Nobody is perfect, and the NFL is filled with guys who made a mistake somewhere along the line.

sportschick · Feb 5, 2007

Moon's wife was bleeding from multiple wounds.

That said, he was a helluva QB, even if I did lose a lot of the respect I had for him after the wife beating came to light.

RAMBO · Feb 5, 2007

sportschick said:

Moon's wife was bleeding from multiple wounds.

That said, he was a helluva QB, even if I did lose a lot of the respect I had for him after the wife beating came to light.
Click to expand...

What happened here?

sportschick · Feb 5, 2007

RAMBO said:

sportschick said:

Moon's wife was bleeding from multiple wounds.

That said, he was a helluva QB, even if I did lose a lot of the respect I had for him after the wife beating came to light.
Click to expand...

What happened here?
Click to expand...

Warren Moon threadjack. Join in or die!

Log in or Sign up

Best QB In NFL History!!!

Who is the best QB in NFL history?

Manning

Montana

Marnio

Brady

Elway

Favre

Unitas

Bradshaw

Staubach

Toretta

RAMBO Member

RAMBO Member

RAMBO Member

GB-Hack Active Member

RAMBO Member

HeinekenMan Active Member

RAMBO Member

outofplace Well-Known Member

HeinekenMan Active Member

sportschick Active Member

RAMBO Member

sportschick Active Member

Share This Page

Log in or Sign up

Best QB In NFL History!!!

Who is the best QB in NFL history?

Manning

Montana

Marnio

Brady

Elway

Favre

Unitas

Bradshaw

Staubach

Toretta

RAMBO Member

RAMBO Member

RAMBO Member

GB-Hack Active Member

RAMBO Member

HeinekenMan Active Member

RAMBO Member

outofplace Well-Known Member

HeinekenMan Active Member

sportschick Active Member

RAMBO Member

sportschick Active Member

Share This Page

Useful Searches