Let me christen the first "American Idol" 2008 thread

You know it.

Seriously, isn't that going to be an issue if she's trying to become a superstar?

 

The only thing sadder than the song Eleanor Rigby was the way this guy sang the song.

 

By the way, I hate Korn, Nickleback and whatever other "alternative rock" band sullies the airways.

 

The panel ain't feeling ya, Devil.

David should be smoking a cigarette right now.

 

Doc and I hated it, too. I knew he'd get applauded, though. The judges love originality.

 

wtf are people thinking with the tats? was she hopelessly drunk when she thought, "this is a good idea?"

love her singing. but tats on women should be small and subtle -- outside on an ankle, on a shoulder blade.

but up and down your arms? awful. :

"eleanor rigby" guy was quite good, imo. 8)

 

I can see how it could be liked, but I just detest the "alternative rock" style of music.

Sing, don't scream.

 

man, i'm sure that's a whole 'nother thread, shockey, but I sure don't get it either.

 

Tats on woman (and I'm guessing the opposite for men) are an all or nothing thing I guess. I can't stand them, but I have friends who go Curly smelling perfume over them.

 

I want to do holy unmentionables to Brooke, who just fuckin killed, BTW.

 

Awwww, Brooke.

I just don't think it was that great, but I think she will live to sing another week.

She should have used a different instrument.

 

You want her to fleck you?