Let me christen the first "American Idol" 2008 thread

Even if he remembered the words, this sucked. Sucked really bad.

 

Fucking call him out for forgetting the words.

 

They actually could have crucified him more than they did.

 

I cannot wait to read the West Coast posts.

I'm waiting for one of them to chime into the thread.

 

Boy, considering the other performances ... how big a hit does Archuleta take for this?

 

Chick and Brooke (the more I think about it the better it was) I think were the stars of the night.

Kristi and David were just awful. Infant spit up awful.

Oh, I forgot that David sang like he had something in his mouth. Like my Alma Mater needs another stain.

 

Never mind. I just saw four people I want off.

 

It's week to week, right?

It's not cumulative.

David survives, but another shit sandwich, and I dunno.

 

It's week to week, but people have developed their favorites, and that probably figures heavily in their balloting.

 

Brooke busts the first word of Let It Be... weird. But she'll survive.

Cook was incredible again.

Carly getting blowjobs from Jackson each week is getting really stale.

 

One at a time from here on out.