NFL playoff thread

But I never said anything of the sort. What "ARGUMENT!!!!!!!" was I making?

Until you look at the overall GPA.

 

except Manning has basically the same quarterback rating in the postseason that he does in the regular season.

 

Yes I do judge HOF QBs on their playoff records. Against the best. Simplistic, perhaps. I like that more than passing yards and TD-INT ratios.

I believe it comes down to: who do you trust is a playoff game?

Manning has lost 5 home playoff games. Steve Young lost 4. Favre lost 3. Brady has lost a few in recent years but his playoff W-L was 14-4 at one point. He has lots of equity here.

Kurt Warner was 7-0 at home and some say he shouldn't be in the HOF. Warren Moon was 3-7 in the playoffs and is.

 

Also, don't forget. Peyton would likely have TWO rings if Reggie Wayne didn't cause him to throw a game-sealing pick 6. Fucking Reggie Wayne.

 

If only playoff games were decided by quarterback rating.

 

Brady's number was once 9-0, wasn't it?

 

Should have used the blue font with my post.

Manning sells a nice steak, but not the sizzle.

 

How much of Peyton Manning's regular-season W-L success has to do with playing in weak divisions? Is it possible - if counterintuitive - that his teams have actually OVERACHIEVED by reaching two Super Bowls?

 

Speaking of compilers, Warren Moon shouldn't be in the Hall of Fame.

 

Pretzel!

 

I did pick up on your blue font.

Didn't want the troglydytes to think they were gaining support.

We can find out.

www.pro-football-reference.com

 

I thought so, too. Maybe his teams weren't nearly as good as we thought. Maybe they are 6-10 teams if someone else is at quarterback. Then when they get in the playoffs against other good teams, they get exposed a bit.