Running 2006-07 NFL Playoffs Thread

I think that Gaffney just caught another uncontested 9 yard out pattern. Some bad mistakes by Chad, but he made some positive plays. Nice game by the happy to be there Jets, but they need a real running back next year.

 

Brian Westbrook sucks and can't stay healthy. [/BYH]

 

Eli Manning has joined the party ladies and gentlemen!

 

Eli Manning is by far the worst QB in the playoffs this year.

 

As Rex Grossman screams, "What about me!"

 

Eli Manning is far worse.

 

And why is McNabb better than Garcia?

 

Because he is. Look, Garcia's had a nice run here. But one huge reason for that success is their newborn reliance on the ground game after McNabb got hurt. Given McNabb's fragile nature, he probably wouldn't complain about handing the ball to Westbrook if it meant a better offense and more wins.

 

why is R.W. McQuarters even attempting to pick up the ball after the Eagles are downing the ball? How 'bout that ol tough as nails Coughlin discipline, huh?

 

Garcia is so good in the WCO. Not surprised he's thriving. At this point in their careers, I agree McNabb is better, but remember, Garcia had enormous number (qb rating, ...) in SF. He just never got his shot for years and years.

McNabb is bigger, his arm is better, and he's a better athlete than Garcia (though not by a lot, Garcia is a hell of an athlete, or was). But Garcia is a better QB than McNabb, in that he makes better decisions and is good under pressure. I give the nod to McNabb based on physical characteristics. That's my take.

 

Is there ANY way he's back next year? I don't even think a super bowl win will save him.