Not sure when Reeve was a baseball player or Cop. But I gave up trying to match more than three categories: no Oscar plus two - and he was an action hero and a missionary.
OK, sorry I was alway so long. Didn't think this would draw this many responses so quickly. Paythrough is the winner. Have played, among others, a general (Gettysburg) A drummer (Eddie & the Cruisters A New York City policeman (Someone to Watch Over me) a fundamentalist missionary (IN the Fields of the Lord) a baseball player (Major League) a sargeant (Platoon) and an action hero. (The Big Chill) Speaking of EATC, where's Frank Ridgeway been?
Hell, Chris Reeve is as good a guess as any. This question's buggin the hell out of me. I'd have to say Berenger, though can't say when he was ever a superhero.
I've got one. Oscar winner. He's played a football player, a soldier, a fisherman and a disabled person.
Tom Cruise comes to mind ... Football - All the Right Moves, Soldier - Born on the Fourth of the July, Disabled person ... well, the same. Fisherman? Fuck, I don't know. When he fished his dad's Porshe out of Lake Michigan in Risky Business?