Yearly Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Debate Thread

again, an amazing player

but were the songs there?

did he write a memorable melody?

 

If you don't remember the melody to "Pride and Joy," just listen to classic rock radio for a half hour.

 

So all it takes to get into the RnRHOF is a memorable song?

Gee, why isn't KISS in for "Rock and Roll All Night"?

Does that mean Jeff Beck, who is a finalist this year, shouldn't get into the RnRHOF? He's already in with the Yardbirds, but his solo stuff is amazing music and much of it non-lyrical.

 

So Yes is awesome, and SRV isn't memorable? Yeesh.

 

My next live BLOG!!!: Finding and beating the shit out of Bubs.

 

a melody has nothing to do with lyrics

 

Music nerd fight!

 

To see good music,
To like good music,
CANNOT BE TAUGHT!!!!!!!

In turn . .
We're making pallister!

Awwwwww . . . . . .FUCKING HOSTILE!!!!!!! (baump bumpalump, bum dum dum, baump bumpalump, bum dum dum, baump bumpalump, bum dum dum, baump bumpalump)

He stands ALONE!!!!!!!!!!

 

It's FIVE MINUTES alone.

BTW, while I enjoy the musical stylings of Pantera, they likely don't make my top 40 favorite bands/artists.

 

Well, that's obvious, if you don't recognize a rewrite of the awesome Fucking Hostile, from Vulgar Display of Power.

Hell, they make my top 40. They had some really enjoyable tunes, both on disc and live.

 

I'm fully aware of your rewrite; I was just bringing up one of Pantera's better songs.

They don't make my top 40 because my musical taste is far superior to most humans and thus I have a lot more stuff to choose from.

 

Eh, whatever. I enjoy their mindless loudness.