W
wickedwritah
Guest
What was your point? Here's your second post, the one I initially addressed:
You said that Storm was run of the mill. You're entitled to that opinion.
But I can only presume "damning with faint praise" was intended to take a shot at the other papers covering Eastern League teams -- and those papers feature some damn good beat writers. And some damn good papers in that pile. I don't know where Storm stands on the EL pantheon -- heck, I've never even heard of her until this thread, though I'm just a casual EL follower -- but the EL beat guys I've read (some of them pretty regularly) are pretty good. If someone's making a value judgment on her work based on other EL writers, I'll presume a.) they know their stuff, have followed the league and just aren't tossing it out there; and b.) she's a decent writer.
Feel free to take issue, that's what a message board is for. But I believe you are damning with faint praise by holding Storm high on the pantheon of Eastern League beat writers. Altoona, Harrisburg, New Hampshire, Bowie, Erie, Binghamton, Portland, New Britain, Reading, Connecticut and Trenton ... is there even a 50k circ paper in there?
Stephanie Storm is what she is: a run-of-the-mill writer/reporter who does nothing particularly special. Reed and McManamon are guys who other papers may line up to hire. Storm is not in that class and is far from it. I'm sure she's a very nice person, but based on her resume and the places she has worked, I'd expect something far more in the way of talent than she has.
You said that Storm was run of the mill. You're entitled to that opinion.
But I can only presume "damning with faint praise" was intended to take a shot at the other papers covering Eastern League teams -- and those papers feature some damn good beat writers. And some damn good papers in that pile. I don't know where Storm stands on the EL pantheon -- heck, I've never even heard of her until this thread, though I'm just a casual EL follower -- but the EL beat guys I've read (some of them pretty regularly) are pretty good. If someone's making a value judgment on her work based on other EL writers, I'll presume a.) they know their stuff, have followed the league and just aren't tossing it out there; and b.) she's a decent writer.