• Welcome to SportsJournalists.com, a friendly forum for discussing all things sports and journalism.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register for a free account to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Access to private conversations with other members.
    • Fewer ads.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Running 2015 MLB Regular-Season Thread

No, really, where's your proof? You being so big on proof and all, I think we all assume you know something we don't.

Or maybe you're just full of shirt as usual.

Of course they're forking lying. Just like every other team that does it. But again, where's you proof?
 
That's the even crazier thing. Right now, he's carrying them offensively. If you would have made a list of their players at the beginning of the season in order of the likelihood that they would be their best hitter, he would have been sixth or seventh on the list.
 
Bryce Harper just hit a home run that damn near cleared the batter's eye at Nats Park.
 
Likely the first time A_QB has shown any interest in proof on this board.

But hey, you want to argue that the Cubs really sent Bryant down for more development, be my guest.

I mean, you have to admit, OOP, given your demands for somehow better proof of Braun's guilt than a failed drug test, it seems odd for you to come down hard on the Cubs for their bullshirt without any proof otherwise.
 
I mean, you have to admit, OOP, given your demands for somehow better proof of Braun's guilt than a failed drug test, it seems odd for you to come down hard on the Cubs for their bullshirt without any proof otherwise.

I didn't come down on them. Please go back and read the entire post, not just the part A_QB bolded.

What I said was that teams have found a way to game the system and the MLBPA should challenge it in the next collective bargaining process if not sooner. I also said that the MLBPA failed the players by allowing this loophole to exist.

If you would like to argue that the Cubs were being honest when they claimed Bryant needed those extra two weeks in the minors, be my guest. I have yet to engage anyone in discussion of the topic who believes that, but there is an argument to be made. Otherwise, you are just piling on for the sake of starting an argument rather than furthering the discussion. I'm not really interested in arguing with people who agree with me, which A_QB clearly does.

But let's be clear, I'm not calling for any action to be taken against the Cubs or any other organization that has taken similar actions with prospects. I am not saying they should be punished or their reputations tarnished.

If you don't think people toss around accusations regarding PED abuse too casually here and elsewhere, which was the point I was making in those Braun discussions, then I can't help you. Some people just refuse to see reason on that point.

I did question the Pirates' handling of Polanco last season in my post, but they didn't just hold him back two weeks, they waited until June to push back the clock on arbitration as well as free agency. That is different from what the Cubs did with Bryant.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top