• Welcome to SportsJournalists.com, a friendly forum for discussing all things sports and journalism.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register for a free account to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Access to private conversations with other members.
    • Fewer ads.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Florio Lectures Rodgers

jlee said:
exmediahack said:
I guess I just don't get the "autograph" thing. My son is 8. He's into it. Fine.

But grown ups? Really? Especially if this day of Twitter and Facebook fan pages. Isn't that enough access?

I'm no autograph-seeker, but playing devil's advocate:

When I was 12 or 13, I got a baseball signed by Lou Piniella for Christmas. I was floored, and it still sits prominently on my bookshelf more than a decade later.

I never met Lou. My dad got the chance, and he took it, swallowing his pride to get something for his son.

This doesn't apply to all or even a majority of autograph-seekers, methinks, but there are thousands of dads, uncles, grandparents and family friends who aren't thinking of themselves when they ask for an autograph.

I have a collection of autographed baseballs from some of my favorite players of my youth.

I always ask the player to personalize it so he is aware that I am not selling it.

More than a few have given me a quizzical look and said it would not be worth as much. I tell them it's not about the money but its about the fond memories they gave me in my youth - priceless.

My favorite baseball - Bob Feller - played before I was born but what a treasure to meet him.
 
Can't remember who it was that told me this story but it was an NFL player who always signed for fans after training camp practices. He said there was "a rule of 100." You sign for 100 people and head for the locker room and the 101st tells everyone what a jerk you are for not signing. Thought Florio went way over the top. This is what happens when "reporters" stop "reporting" and start "guessing" what happened.
 
Dr. Howard said:
Can't remember who it was that told me this story but it was an NFL player who always signed for fans after training camp practices. He said there was "a rule of 100." You sign for 100 people and head for the locker room and the 101st tells everyone what a jerk you are for not signing. Thought Florio went way over the top. This is what happens when "reporters" stop "reporting" and start "guessing" what happened.
And making their own conclusions before finding out about "the rest of the story."

I don't have a major hangup with adults asking for autographs, as long as they act like adults, and not like screaming pentulant kids. Personally, I don't like asking for autographs. It makes me feel uncomfortable, and secondly if I see them outside of their workplace (store, bar, etc.), I don't bother them.

The only exception is that if a friend or a pal knows them personally and introduces us, I'll be happy to get a handshake and tell them it's a pleasure meeting them. Beyond that, if he wants to chat me up, I'm cool with that.

As far as Florio, I'll give him credit for writing that apology and mea culpa. He didn't have to do it at all.

Gregg Doyel, you are still my hero.
 
jlee said:
exmediahack said:
I guess I just don't get the "autograph" thing. My son is 8. He's into it. Fine.

But grown ups? Really? Especially if this day of Twitter and Facebook fan pages. Isn't that enough access?

I'm no autograph-seeker, but playing devil's advocate:

When I was 12 or 13, I got a baseball signed by Lou Piniella for Christmas. I was floored, and it still sits prominently on my bookshelf more than a decade later.

I never met Lou. My dad got the chance, and he took it, swallowing his pride to get something for his son.

This doesn't apply to all or even a majority of autograph-seekers, methinks, but there are thousands of dads, uncles, grandparents and family friends who aren't thinking of themselves when they ask for an autograph.

Not many anymore. It's all for the memorabilia market.


D-3 Fan said:
As far as Florio, I'll give him credit for writing that apology and mea culpa. He didn't have to do it at all.

Well, he did if he didn't want to look like an absolute knob -- only about an 85% knob.
 
D-3 Fan said:
As far as Florio, I'll give him credit for writing that apology and mea culpa. He didn't have to do it at all.

He pretty much had to after he wrote that second post after the initial column, and was proven completely off-base when the woman went on camera and he finally looked into the details surrounding it. He didn't just have an egg on his face, he had a couple dozen.

And I'm still not buying that NBC didn't make an influential suggestion to him to make an apology.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top