• Welcome to SportsJournalists.com, a friendly forum for discussing all things sports and journalism.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register for a free account to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Access to private conversations with other members.
    • Fewer ads.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Oklahoma State coach Gundy blasts Oklahoman columnist

That color-coding gimmick reveals little beyond the coder's own subjectivity. As someone else noted, there's plenty of overlap where others would paint red this guy's black/green areas. And what's painted black is highly speculative itself--doggone it he's pretty sure she really did have solid inside sources for that info, despite the fact that she only attributed it to "rumors, rumblings, etc." in the actual piece. And what gets green as "fair" speculation likewise depends largely upon on the personal opinion of the guy with the crayons.
 
Come on, Tulsa World. That required a bylined story? A Houston TV station gets its worthless little piece of the pie five days after the fact (news flash! A mother doesn't like her son being portrayed as a wuss!), and you write a day-after regurgitation of that?

Stop the madness, indeed.
 
IU90 said:
Besides that, he's wrong, Read again, Okie.

"According to a source in the OSU program, Rajika Reid did attend the game at Troy."

You're right. I read the word "didn't" in that sentence.
 
ADifferentOkie said:
IU90 said:
Besides that, he's wrong, Read again, Okie.

"According to a source in the OSU program, Rajika Reid did attend the game at Troy."

You're right. I read the word "didn't" in that sentence.

nobody is bagging on you, dog. at least i hope you didn't read that into my last post.
 
Tom Petty said:
ADifferentOkie said:
IU90 said:
Besides that, he's wrong, Read again, Okie.

"According to a source in the OSU program, Rajika Reid did attend the game at Troy."

You're right. I read the word "didn't" in that sentence.

nobody is bagging on you, dog. at least i hope you didn't read that into my last post.

Nah, but I did want to clear up the confusion. I just read the sentence wrong.
If his mom hadn't been there, it would severely undermine Carlson's claims to have the facts right.
 
JerrySix said:
hondo said:
I've read the column five times now, and I still think it was a good column. If there are parts that are vague or could have used better sourcing, it's partly the fault of Gundy for not being more forthcoming about why the second coming of Vince Young was benched for reasons unrelated to injuries. If coaches don't like speculation of this kind, they should be a bit more up front -- not that I'm holding my breath for that. But they love having it both ways: refuse to explain why they benched someone or called the play they did, then scream when a columnist or writer is forced to use other means to explain what the coach won't. All, I might add, in an effort to serve the reader, who in this case, would probably like to know why this kid was benched.

If you read the column four times, then you're a moron to make such a post. In the article, Carlson writes: "Even though Mike Gundy said last week that Robinson got the nod because he had the better week of practice, insiders say that the coaches decided to bench Reid early in the week." GUNDY DID TELL HER WHY THE CHANGE WAS MADE. How can you say he didn't. Carlson chose to believe "insiders" instead of what the coach said, on the record.

How can you make a claim that Gundy didn't give a reason? He gave a reason. Carlson chose not to believe it.
Let's see ... Reid is among the most high-profile recruits Ok. St. has signed in recent years. Has shown so much talent that people were calling him another Vince Young. And he's benched for one week of poor practices? That's it?
That's can't be the only reason, as Ms. Carlson was trying to find out.

And by the way, why the insults for posting my opinion, especially about a sports-related issue. Save your sophomoric personal insults for the politics board, where Fenian and JR rant and rule.
 
Why did this make me laugh?

From the comments section under the Tulsa article:
10. 9/27/2007 2:48:01 PM, Randy, Tulsa
CHUNCK CHUNCK CHICKEN.

TROJAN HORSE OF TROY.

WHO WAS THERE? WHO WAS NOT THERE? THAT IS THE QUESTION?

JENNI ATE THE CHICKEN.

KENTUCKY FRIED CHICKEN? CHURCH'S CHICKEN?

WAL-MART CHICKEN? CHICKEN ON THE BONE? CHICKEN STRIPS? DARK MEAT? WHITE MEAT?

BAKED OR FRIED? IS REID CHICKEN? OR HE ATE CHICKEN?

JENNI DOESN'T KNOW FOOTBALL SHE HAS NEVER PLAYED THE GAME.

CHUNK CHUNK CHICKEN

CHICKEN CHICKEN CHICKEN

OSU FINALLY WON A GAME BEAT A RANKED TEAM

WHO CARES ABOUT THE CHICKEN?

JENNI CARES ABOUT THE CHICKEN.
 
Christ, not that "they never played the game," about the media.
Football is a pretty simple game. Coaches try to make it as complicated as possible to cover their ashes and create the illusion, as Jim Mora so eloquently put it, that "we won't know and we can't know."
Guess what coaches ... we do know, and so do most of your knowledgable fans who watch and attend games. And that scares the crap out of you.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top