• Welcome to SportsJournalists.com, a friendly forum for discussing all things sports and journalism.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register for a free account to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Access to private conversations with other members.
    • Fewer ads.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

NFL Week 8 -- Primetime blues

He's not, but so far Geno Smith looks like the best quarterback Cleveland has faced all season. Amazing handful of plays so far.
 
I think Greg Zuerlein gets overlooked when talking about the game's great kickers. He's been pretty much money for a long time. 82.6% on field goals lifetime.
 
It's more that you have NO idea what you're getting week to week, and there's little logic to why he struggles or succeeds one week to another. He seems moody both on and off the field and it shows in the way he plays.

He and Gardner Minshew are in the same category.

That would be the comp guy - I've banged the drum for Minshew, but the performance just isn't there. They are both like my golf game - I hit one amazing shot - perfect - and I think THAT is what kind of golfer I am - and figure all the crummy shots and mis hits are anomolies - just freakish things. When in reality I am more the latter than the former.
 
He's not, but so far Geno Smith looks like the best quarterback Cleveland has faced all season. Amazing handful of plays so far.
He's come back to Earth after the first quarter.

And until the Seahawks start looking for/stopping the screens, no reason for the Browns to quit running them.
 
That would be the comp guy - I've banged the drum for Minshew, but the performance just isn't there. They are both like my golf game - I hit one amazing shot - perfect - and I think THAT is what kind of golfer I am - and figure all the crummy shots and mis hits are anomolies - just freakish things. When in reality I am more the latter than the former.

Minshew is a great backup quarterback. He's capable enough to step in and give you a chance when he's suddenly thrown into a game, and will play well enough to keep you treading water for a few weeks. But if you have to go more than four or five games with him his shortcomings will get exposed. He's a .500 (or slightly below) quarterback, which is great if you need a fill-in and not so great when you need him to carry you for an entire season.
Mayfield is probably a tick above that, in that he might be able to pull your team to a wild card spot.
Neither guy is winning a Super Bowl.
 
Last edited:
I never thought Will Levis would have one game in the NFL like the one he had today.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top